Star Wars : Episode 3, La Revanche des Sith - Edition Collector 2 DVD

Les editions DVD de Star wars se suivent et se ressemblent aussi bien dans leur irreprochable qualite technique qu'au niveau du contenu editorial. Parmi l'avalanche de supplements proposes, on retiendra l'impressionnant mais technique commentaire audio, le precieux et passionnant making of, les scenes inedites (dont l'exil de Yoda), les exhaustifs documents internet, la galerie de photos. Moins fournie en nombre de bonus que celle de l'Episode II, cette edition n'en gagne pas moins la bataille de l'interet, et permet de faire la lumiere sur l'enorme machine de production qui se cache derriere Star wars. - www.ecranlarge.com

Ce film est inutilement violent et hautement stupide. Enfin, je parle pour la generation des + de 30 ans bien evidemment. On retrouve un peu des Matrix 2, 3 dans leur genre sauce manga en bien pire. Le plus etonnant est qu'il n'y a aucune scene digne de la fin de l'Episode II. Rien! Seule une maigre sequence spatiale en debut de film mais on a vu BIEN MIEUX dans la 1ere trilogie!! Pour ceux qui comme moi esperaient un nouveau retour du Jedi c'est diablement rape. On reste sur des combats indigestes epee contre epee a la mode japoniaise sans humanite. Peu d'entre nous ont pu apprecie le seul denouement du film vu qu'il fait PARTIE INTEGRANTE de sa Bande-Annonce tres fortement mediatisee! C'est parfaitement irrespectueux cher M. Lucas vis a vis des fans!!! Il n'y a rien a retenir de ce film.


Come over to the dark side...   Février 8, 2006
FrKurt Messick (Bloomington, IN USA)
5 sur 7 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile

When the first Star Wars film came out, I was 11 years old. I loved it (no surprise there). I saw it dozens of times, a feat which at that time in history could only be accomplished by going to the cinema over and over. This year I turn 40, and the long saga of Star Wars is over (at least officially). George Lucas, long-time friend of Joseph Campbell (best known for his work on mythology and spirituality) set out with the Skywalker saga to set up a modern mythological tale that could instill values and virtues the way that old heroic tales a la Hercules might have done from their times and cultures. Not too far off, Lucas was (as Yoda might say), but while the Star Wars saga does show a good interplay of good and evil, in this particular film, the waters become muddied. Perhaps this is because, instead of influencing the times, the times are influencing the story line. But I'm getting ahead of myself here.

One needs to have a strange sort of sympathy for Lucas, Dykstra and company in the special effects department. How does one continue to amaze and wow the crowd of today's cinema-goers while not making the original film (1977 was a long time ago, even if in the local galaxy) look cheesy and dated, because ultimately, the original film has to be found in the fourth slot in later runs. In this respect, they've done a good job. The opening shot of one lone star ship running from a much larger cruiser will no longer have the cinematic effect that it once had, particularly after an opening such as this film had - the scene starts with two small speeders, going up to a ship that gets ever larger, and then one behold a vast armarda of similar ships just around the bending horizon of this one. Alas, Tie-Fighters and X-Wing fighters do seem a bit dated...

There were a few points at which the CGI and matting didn't seem to have a seamless effect - one could tell the images of Anakin and Obi-Wan were superimposed over the lava jets and flows at times, but the action did keep one from dwelling it. The non-space sets were magnificent as ever, and the galactic geography was added to with several new planets with differing terrains.

The plot for this third episode was in some ways predetermined. We know episodes two and four, so the real drama turns on three major points, and one set-up for episode four. First, the chancellor must become the dictatorial emperor. There was no mystery from the very outset of episode one that he would end up in this role - one wonders if, in the future, people watching the series in proper sequence will discover that so quickly. Second, the Jedi order must meet its doom (otherwise, why would a later episode be entitled 'Return of the Jedi'?). Of course, part of this must require the survival of Yoda and Obi-Wan, as they recur in the future. Third, Anakin must become Darth Vader. We know he will, the question is, how? The set-up comes from the birth of Luke and Leia, who will prove the good-guy nemesis duo of Vader in the latter half of the series.

For having so many predetermined arcs, the story is riveting in many ways. Anakin makes a slow descent into the temptations of the dark side, and most of the time, it is believable - Anakin is still a brash, aggressive young man, full of himself and with all the arrogance that fame and strength can bring. He does give up a bit too easily to the dark side (and one wonders why it never occurred to him that his dreams might be a manipulative plant rather than a true vision of the future). Palpatine becomes the grizzled, disfigured emperor by use of the dark side, just as Anakin will suffer a similar fate. Yoda seems to give up a bit too easily in the final fight with Palpatine - again, required for the story arc, but disappointing given the invincibility factor attributed to Yoda throughout much of the story (this film and others).

Padme is ever-present, but not very effective save as the object of interest for young Anakin; again, we know their love is doomed because we've seen the future, but exactly how they split becomes part of the drama, and it is generally well done. Jar-Jar shows up in the background occasionally, but doesn't utter a word. Chewbacca makes his first appearance here, and several characters make their last.

The battle between Obi-Wan and Anakin in the end is very well crafted, both from a psychological and physical standpoint.

Both Hayden Christensen and Ewan McGregor do an excellent job with their characters. There is subtlety and finesse, even in the choreography for the fight scenes; their relationship is solidly developed. Natalie Portman is a bit wasted, with very little action allowed, given that she is pregnant (with twins, no less - it is somewhat lacking in credibility that this super-advanced civilisation would not have the ability to detect that she was carrying twins, but I digress). All other actors do their usual good job - nothing outstanding nor detracting from the overall Star Wars effect.

Despite the dark and ominous overtones, and despite the pre-set trajectory of much of the action in the film, it is still one that manages to inspire awe and keep one's attention; the dramatic pace of the film is well done, and the acting credible enough without only a few story-line drops distracting from an otherwise near-flawless execution.

It has been officially proclaimed as the last film in the Star Wars cycle. However, there might yet be room for Star Wars III.5. The character of Obi-Wan wants for more development, and his last exchange with Yoda leaves the door open for a side-venture. Don't count the saga out yet.